GitCorner

Code

ossartcraftlightcraft๐ŸŒ
5a24289898fd
hardware-parity.mdRendered Markdown

Hardware parity

Last reviewed: 2026-10-10 ยท Target: Adobe Lightroom Classic 15.5 / Lightroom 9.6 ยท Changes: revision history

What Lightroom does with the machine's hardware, per platform, and what LightCraft does. Sources: gpu-pipeline.md, display-profiles.md, denoise.md, ai-masks.md, crates/gpu, crates/engine/src/devices.rs, crates/ui-egui/src/panels/second.rs.

Feature Target LightCraft: macOS Windows Linux / BSD Web Status
GPU for display and editing Metal / DX12, "Use GPU for display / image processing / export" wgpu Metal: geometry, resize, blur, WB, NR, guided filter, dehaze, masks, finish; CPU fallback per render DX12 only (Vulkan opt-in, #136) Vulkan (CPU โ†” GPU equivalence verified on an AMD Radeon 8060S, RADV) CPU only (no WebGPU yet) ๐ŸŸก defringe, spot removal, heuristic masks, long brushes and high-bit exports stay on CPU
GPU export โœ… โœ… (6000 ร— 4000 in ~0.3 s vs ~1.2 s CPU) โœ… โœ… โ€” โœ… (black-export fix on an Intel iGPU, #78)
AI on GPU / neural engine Metal / DirectML / Core ML, model per feature AI denoise on GPU or CPU (setting); SAM 3 on Metal via candle; faces on CPU CPU / GPU denoise CPU / GPU denoise โ€” ๐ŸŸก no Core ML / Neural Engine / DirectML
HDR (EDR) display โœ… (macOS EDR, Windows HDR) โฌœ โฌœ โฌœ โฌœ โฌœ (LR-VIEW-HDR-DISPLAY)
Monitor profile automatic per display, follows the window โœ… the screen's profile, followed across screens โœ… the profile Windows Color System assigns to the window's monitor, followed across monitors and profile changes; sRGB while Windows colour-manages the desktop (HDR, Auto Color Management) ๐ŸŸก colord's profile (one display, or all sharing one); no follow across monitors โ€” ๐ŸŸก Linux per-monitor follow missing
Second window / second monitor โœ… (Classic) โœ… (โŒ˜F11) โœ… โœ… โ€” โœ… (Classic secondary-window keys missing)
Pen pressure / tilt (brush masks) โœ… pressure for size / flow โฌœ winit reports no tablet pressure on macOS ๐ŸŸก pen force from winit touch events (untested on a tablet) โฌœ winit has no X11 / Wayland tablet input ๐ŸŸก pointer-event force where winit passes it ๐ŸŸก brush size and flow follow pen pressure wherever egui gets a touch force (Brush โ–ธ Pen Pressure); no tilt; macOS / Linux tablets wait on winit
Trackpad gestures pinch zoom, pan โœ… pinch, two-finger pan ๐ŸŸก (winit) ๐ŸŸก ๐ŸŸก โœ… on macOS
Card readers / cameras as import sources โœ… (devices panel, eject after import) โœ… mounted volumes with DCIM โœ… โœ… โ€” ๐ŸŸก no eject-after-import check, no MTP / PTP phones
Tethered capture โœ… Classic (Canon, Nikon, Sony, Leica) โฌœ โฌœ โฌœ โ€” โฌœ
Printers โœ… Print module, printer colour management โฌœ (PDF contact sheets only) โฌœ โฌœ โ€” โฌœ
Control surfaces (MIDI / Loupedeck via plug-ins) via SDK plug-ins control channel and MCP can drive every command same same โ€” ๐ŸŸก different mechanism; no MIDI mapping
Multi-core CPU โœ… โœ… worker pools, parallel JPEG decode, parallel import copy โœ… โœ… single thread โœ…
Memory pressure managed โœ… memory budget, crates/sysmem returns allocator pages on macOS โœ… budget โœ… budget โ€” โœ…

Score

~40% ready (estimated): the GPU editing path is real and fast (measured: 24 MP exposure drag 3.9 ms on GPU vs 22โ€“42 ms CPU; NR drag 18 ms vs 301โ€“471 ms), but HDR display, pen pressure, tethering, printing, per-monitor profiles on Linux and neural-engine inference are missing. GPU correctness is proven on Apple GPUs and on one AMD GPU on Linux (Radeon 8060S, Vulkan / RADV: the equivalence suite passes with the same max 1โ€“2 LSB as on Metal, gpu-pipeline.md). NVIDIA, Intel and Windows DX12 still rely on user reports.

Remaining (Opus 5.5 agent hours)

Work Hours Needs
HDR display (EDR on macOS, Windows HDR, Linux where possible) 10โ€“20 an HDR display to verify (human)
OS monitor profile: follow the window across displays on Linux 2โ€“4 multi-monitor setup
Pen pressure for brush masks: done where winit reports a touch force; macOS and Linux tablets need winit tablet events (or a pure-Rust tablet layer) 3โ€“8 a tablet
Remaining stages on GPU (defringe, spot removal, masks) 10โ€“20
Tethered capture (PTP over USB in pure Rust, Canon / Nikon / Sony first) 25โ€“45 cameras (human)
Printing with colour management 15โ€“25 printers (human)
Neural-engine / DirectML inference for AI features 10โ€“20 depends on the AI model decision
Total 75โ€“142 h (the core set for beta, HDR display + monitor profile + pen pressure: 15โ€“32 h)

Revision history

Date Change Summary
2026-10-20 minor Monitor profile: Windows reads the window's monitor profile from Windows Color System (crates/wincolor), sRGB while Windows colour-manages the desktop; verified on Windows 11 by setting and clearing a Display P3 profile while the app ran. Remaining monitor-profile work 4โ€“8 h โ†’ 2โ€“4 h
2026-10-12 minor Monitor profile: Linux reads the display profile from colord; macOS row reflects #787
2026-10-12 minor CPU โ†” GPU equivalence suite run on an AMD Radeon 8060S (Vulkan, RADV, Linux): 16 tests / 135 cases pass, max 2 LSB, mean โ‰ค 0.0003; first GPU verified outside Apple
2026-10-12 minor Pen pressure: strokes record per-point pressure from egui touch force, scaling dab size and flow; per-platform status
2026-10-10 major Created